Calculator category
Heating Costs
Heating is the largest energy cost in most cold-climate homes, and the hardest to reason about, because the fuel price and the useful heat are separated by your system's efficiency. A cheap fuel through a wasteful boiler can cost more than an expensive fuel used well.
The calculators here compare fuels on equal terms — the same heat demand priced through each system — and price the plug-in heaters that so often fill the gaps.
The Heating Costs category holds 2 calculators: Heating Cost Calculator, Electric Heater Cost Calculator. Each one answers a part of the same question, and together they answer the whole of it. The point of the category is not to give you separate answers that do not agree with each other, but to give you one answer that you can trust, built from the parts that matter most in your own home.
Start with Heating Cost Calculator. It is the calculator in this category that takes the broadest view, and its result is the number the other calculators refine. Run it first, with the numbers from a recent bill, and write the result down: it is the baseline against which every other figure in the category should be judged, and it is the figure to come back to when a later calculation surprises you.
Then use the other calculators in the category to break that baseline down. Electric Heater Cost Calculator takes one part of the total and works it out in detail, so you can see whether that part is large because the quantity is large, because the rate is high, or because the efficiency is low. That is the question this category is really asking, and it is the question that decides what to do next, because the remedy for a large quantity is different from the remedy for a high rate.
Before you run any of these calculators, gather the numbers they all need. The first is annual heat demand (Useful heat your home needs per year. Starting point shown: 12,000 kWh — replace it with your own figure.), and the second is your rate, taken from a recent bill rather than from a preset average. With those two numbers in hand, every calculator in this category gives you an answer about your home; without them, it gives you an answer about an average home, and the difference between the two is often larger than the saving you are trying to measure.
Calculators in this category
What drives the cost
- Heat demand: how much warmth your home actually needs, driven by insulation, draughts, size and climate.
- Fuel price per kWh — gas is usually cheapest per unit, electricity dearest, oil in between and volatile.
- System efficiency: older fossil-fuel furnaces and boilers can have AFUE ratings of roughly 56–70% (U.S. Department of Energy), meaning around 30–44% of the fuel's energy is not converted into useful seasonal heat; actual performance varies with equipment type, age, condition, installation and operation. A heat pump returns 2–4 kWh of heat per kWh of electricity.
- Standing charges and delivery minimums, especially for oil and LPG, which reward bulk buying.
- The result in this category is most sensitive to the quantity you enter first, because the formula multiplies by it. A quantity that is wrong by a tenth makes the answer wrong by a tenth, and no amount of precision in the other inputs can repair that.
Ways to save
- Cut demand before changing systems: draught-proofing and insulation lower the bill under every fuel.
- Service combustion boilers; a sooted, badly tuned boiler wastes fuel you have already bought.
- Heat the rooms you use, when you use them — zoning and timers beat heating an empty house evenly.
- If you use plug-in heaters regularly, price them with the Electric Heater Calculator — they are the most expensive heat in most homes.
- Re-run the calculators in this category together whenever one of their shared inputs changes. A new rate, a new appliance or a new pattern of use changes every calculator that uses it, and running them together is how you keep the answers consistent with each other.
Country differences
UK homes heat mostly with gas boilers; in England, Approved Document L sets a 92% ErP minimum efficiency for a gas-fired wet heating system in an existing dwelling (lower SEDBUK 2009 figures only in exceptional circumstances), and the Ofgem cap prices gas well below electricity per kWh.
In much of the rural US and Canada, heating oil and propane serve homes off the gas grid, priced per gallon or litre with strong seasonal swings.
Heat pumps are now the default new heating system in several cold countries because their 200–400% effective efficiency rewrites the fuel comparison.
Frequently asked questions
What is my heat demand and where do I find it?
It is the useful heat your home needs in a year, in kWh. Past fuel bills (converted to kWh), an energy performance certificate, or a heating engineer's sizing calculation all give a figure. Comparing your current fuel use ÷ boiler efficiency is a good estimate.
Is a heat pump really 300% efficient?
It does not create heat; it moves it. One kWh of electricity can carry 2–4 kWh of heat indoors, which is expressed as a COP of 2–4, or "200–400%". Performance falls in very cold weather — the seasonal average (SCOP) is the honest number.
Why doesn't this site pre-fill gas or oil prices?
Because they span too wide a range — by country, contract and season — for a default to be honest. The Heating Calculator asks for yours and says so.
Where should I start in the Heating Costs category?
Start with Heating Cost Calculator, using the numbers from a recent bill, and write the result down. Then run Electric Heater Cost Calculator for the part of the total you most want to understand, and compare its result with the first calculator result. If the two disagree, check the inputs they share, the quantity and the rate, before you trust either answer.